Verified Document

Eating Disorders The Argument Regarding The Medical Research Paper

Eating Disorders The argument regarding the medical and ethical treatment of anorexia nervosa patients has been highly debated throughout the medical and philosophical circles. On the one side, there is the belief that doctors can only go so far before forced treatment and involuntary hospitalizations should be unethical. On the other hand, doctors have taken their oaths to do everything they possibly can to save a patient's life, even to the point of expertly deciding the fate of the patient, regardless of the patient's contrary decisions. The general argument -- pointed out by the likes of James L. Werth (2003) and Heather Draper (2002) -- lies in the premise that one inflicted with anorexia nervosa is incapable of thinking competently. This incompetency thus allows medical experts the ultimate decision of involuntarily hospitalizing the patient and/or subjecting the patient to a forced treatment for the disorder. Doctors alike have taken their respective oaths to protect and serve the clients to the best of their abilities, so long as the client is willing and fully aware of the impending methods.

In that line of thought, if the person suffering from said anorexia is proven to be mentally competent, how does one draw the line for medical experts to undergo an intervention? Once again, the question here becomes a matter of the patient's competence. A refusal for forced treatment or involuntary hospitalization should be determined on that competency basis....

This forced treatment on a competent person would be akin to resuscitating a DNR signee. However, in all other cases where the person is clearly incapable of rational and competent thought over her disorder, the case of involuntary hospitalization and forced treatment should be an inevitable step in the medical and ethical direction.
That said, doctors are responsible for providing medical aid and protection to the best of their abilities. How far must one draw the line, however, before the patient is well beyond one's help (Werth, 2003)? After explaining to the patient and the patient has reasoned that her life is past help (owing to her extremely poor quality of life, constant hospitalization, and bodily failure), then surely here the doctor would be transgressing on dangerous ground should he or she continue with the treatment. The patient no longer desires treatment; the patient has moved past the stage of wanting to hold on, perhaps even to the psychological point that any treatment would result in a failure. The patient in this situation -- while acting upon a more aggressive reflex -- is competent. She does not want treatment, any more than a DNR individual does not want…

Sources used in this document:
Resources

Draper, Heather. (2002). Anorexia nervosa and respecting a refusal of life-prolonging therapy: a limited justification. Bioethics, 14(2), 261-278.

Werth, James L. Jr., et. al. (2003). When does the "duty to protect" apply with a client who has anorexia nervosa?. The Counseling Psychologist, 31(3).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Eating Disorders and Perception of Beauty
Words: 3190 Length: 11 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Eating Disorders How the Perception of Beauty Influences Eating Disorders With everything changing in this society, the aspect of beauty especially when it comes to women has kept changing, sometimes desperately to the extent of individuals adopting extreme behaviors in the pursuit of the ideal 'beauty'. Instances where different kinds of media communicate the significance of physical beauty in the contemporary world and the means of achieving such traits are widespread. The

Controversy Regarding Childhood Obesity, As This Is
Words: 897 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

controversy regarding childhood obesity, as this is a pressing matter and as there are more and more cases involving children becoming obese as a result of a series of factors involving poor nutrition, little to no exercise, and a general failure to understand why it is important for them to adopt attitudes that can maintain them healthy. The percentage of children becoming obese has experienced a steady increase in

Anorexia According to Guissinguer 2003 Anorectics, "...React
Words: 2104 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Anorexia According to guissinguer (2003) anorectics, "...react to loss of body weight by displaying adaptive responses that originally evolved to facilitate leaving food depleted areas." Discuss. Anorexia is a disorder attributed to attempts to attain a fashionable shape, but numerous studies suggest that it is possible for psychological and societal factors to contribute in the development of this disorder. According to Kaye et al. (1998), anorexia is a disorder characterized by unusual

Mental Illness: What's in a
Words: 2556 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

When one throws the element of ethnicity into the mix, the process of diagnosis becomes even more difficult. Let us take, for instance the effect of religion on the diagnosis of a mental illness. In some religions it is considered to be "normal" to experience visions, see ghosts, and talk to the dead. However, from a strict clinical standpoint, these things do not exist and therefore indicate a break from

Obesity in Pregnancy Brief Actionplan
Words: 4542 Length: 15 Document Type: Dissertation

The chapters outlined the significance of the study, the intended objectives, the hypotheses statements, justification of the study, the research design, and the findings and conclusions. The examination carried out within the sections of this paper will be important for bridging the gap of knowledge on the use of UB-PAP in the diagnosis of obesity among obese pregnant mothers. It will be particularly helpful in informing the patients and

Sex Appeal to Market Our Athletes
Words: 4505 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

They are there to play and not to show off their bodies. Female athletes with larger body size will find discomforts in the tightly fitted uniforms. This then presents problem to safety. The female athletes who will not be at ease to the required uniform could not focus on the game she is playing. She will, from time to time, try to rearrange, pull or push some parts o the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now